Vedic math vs authentic Indian gaṇita

C. K. Raju

c.k.raju@ganita.guru

"Vedic math" has NOTHING to do with Veda-s

The real math found in the Veda

Name "Vedic" in "Vedic math" misleading: used only to CHEAT people

  • that "Vedic math" has some connection with Veda.
  • Using name of Veda to cheat and mislead demeans the Veda.
  • It is gross disservice to Hinduism.

"Ancient" hence "Vedic"?

  • (Atul Kothari said that it is.)
  • WRONG claim. Everything ancient is NOT "Vedic"!
  • Lokayata, Buddhists, Jains REJECTED belief in Veda-s or related शब्द प्रमाण.
  • Lokayata said that moksha is laughable,

that "three authors of the Veda were buffoons, knaves and demons".

  • Can't say this is "Vedic"!😖

Anyway, no evidence "Vedic math" is ancient 😀

  • Our source modern: Bharati Krishna Tirtha.
  • Could not explain his sources when asked by K. S. Shukla, ca. 1950.
  • Vedic math" NOT found in ANY traditional Indian math/astronomy text
  • from Vedanga Jyotiṣa (\(-1500\) CE) to Yuktibhāṣa +1500 CE across 3000 years.

Vedic math AGAINST authentic Indian tradition

"Vedic math" has limited use

  • At BEST good for mental calculations in arithmetic
  • for competitive tests where a calculator cannot be used.
  • There are many such systems of mental arithmetic.
  • No proper comparison done: cultural loyalty solely due to misleading term "Vedic".
  • Teach mental arithmetic if you want, but remove the false term "Vedic".

Authentic Indian gaṇita VERY useful for current S&T

Or see these scholarly writings

Conclusion

  • Drop the false term "Vedic" in Vedic math.
  • Teach authentic Indian gaṇita as in myb alternative math curriculum (from primary schol on)
  • Useful for future technology development and the need to create skilled people (technology about people)
  • and makes a strong and valid statement about India's cultural pride and its contemporary relevance.

Created: 2023-06-18 Sun 05:09

Validate